Curating the Biolink Model

Before curating the Biolink Model, we recommend that you familiarize yourself with the basics of LinkML.

In Biolink Model all the curation should happen in one place: biolink-model.yaml This is the one source of truth for the model.

This section explores how to go about adding new classes and slots to the model.

Adding an Entity class

An entity class represents entities like Genes, Diseases, Chemical Substances, etc.

Instances of these Entity classes are represented as nodes in a graph.

Biolink Model has several entity classes like gene, disease, phenotypic feature, chemical substance.

All these classes are arranged in a hierarchy with the root of all entities being the named thing class.

To add an entity class to Biolink Model you need to determine the following,

What is an appropriate name for this entity?
- The name for an entity should be clear and concise. It should describe instances of this class
Where in the named thing hierarchy does the new class fit?
- Determine what the immediate parent for this class is going to be
What are the slots that this class can have (in addition to its inherited slots)?
- Determine what additional properties that this class ought to have
Do certain slots have to be constrained to certain values?
- Determine whether there are properties (new or inherited) whose value have to be constrained to a certain value space
What are the valid namespace prefixes for identifiers of instances of this class?
- For representing an instance of this entity class determine the identifier namespace and valid prefix(es)
What are the mapping(s) for this class?
- Mappings are a way of rooting this new entity classs in the context of other ontologies, thesauri, controlled vocabularies and taxonomies
- Determine the level of granularity for your mappings where they can be divided into 5 types: related_mappings, broad_mappings, narrow_mappings close_mappings, exact_mappings

As an example, let’s consider the definition of the entity class gene:

  gene:
    is_a: gene or gene product
    aliases: ['locus']
    slots:
      - id
      - name
      - symbol
      - description
      - synonym
      - xref
    exact_mappings:
      - SO:0000704
      - SIO:010035
      - WIKIDATA:Q7187
    id_prefixes:
      - NCBIGene
      - ENSEMBL
      - HGNC
      - UniProtKB
      - MGI
      - ZFIN
      - dictyBase
      - WB
      - WormBase
      - FlyBase
      - FB
      - RGD
      - SGD
      - PomBase

In the above YAML snippet, is_a, aliases, slots, exact_mappings, and id_prefixes are slots from linkML where each slot has a specific meaning and they add semantics to the class definition.

In addition to the aforementioned slots, linkML provides ways to leverage mixin classes to reuse certain slots across different classes.

Say you want to use the mixin class thing with taxon that defines an in taxon slot.

You can achieve that as follows:

  gene:
    is_a: gene or gene product
    mixins:
      - thing with taxon
    aliases: ['locus']
    ...

In the above YAML snippet, we are explicitly defining the entity class gene to have in taxon as a slot in addition to all its slots, its parent slots, and all of its ancestor slots.

There are other linkML slots that can be used to define your class and further capture the semantics of your class.

For more information on what each slot means and how to use them in Biolink Model, refer to Using the Modeling Language.

Adding an Association class

An association represents an assertion (statement) which connects a subject to an object via a predicate.

Instances of the Association class are represented as edges in a graph.

Biolink Model has several Association classes like gene to gene association, gene to disease association, disease to phenotypic feature association.

All these classes are arranged in a hierarchy with the root of all associations being the association class.

To add an Association class to Biolink Model you need to determine the following,

What is an appropriate name for this association
- The name for an association should be clear and concise. It should capture the type of assertion that it is trying to represent
What type of nodes does this association link?
- Determine what the subject and the object classes are in this assertion
Where in the hierarchy does the new class fit?
- Determine where in the association slot hierarchy does this new assocation class fit
What are the slots that this association class can have (in addition to inherited slots)?
- Determine what additional properties that this class ought to have
Do certain slots have to be constrained on what values it ought to have?
- Determine whethere there are properties (new or inherited) whose value have to be constrained to a certain value space
What are the mapping(s) for this class?
- Mappings are a way of rooting this new association in the context of other ontologies, thesauri, controlled vocabularies and taxonomies
- Determine the level of granularity for your mappings where they can be divided into 5 types: related_mappings, broad_mappings, narrow_mappings close_mappings, exact_mappings

As an example, let’s consider the definition of class variant to disease association:

  variant to disease association:
    is_a: association
    defining_slots:
      - subject
      - object
    mixins:
      - variant to thing association
      - entity to disease association
    slot_usage:
      subject:
        description: >-
          a sequence variant in which the allele state is associated in some way with the disease state
        examples:
          - value: ClinVar:52241
            description: "NM_000059.3(BRCA2):c.7007G>C (p.Arg2336Pro)"
      relation:
        description: >-
          E.g. is pathogenic for
        subproperty_of: related condition
      object:
        description: >-
          a disease that is associated with that variant
        examples:
          - value: MONDO:0016419
            description: hereditary breast cancer

In the above YAML snippet, is_a, defining_slots, mixins, and slot_usage are slots from linkML where each slot has a specific meaning and they add semantics to the class definition.

There are other linkML slots that can be used to define your class and represent the semantics of your class.

For more information on what each slot means and how to use them in Biolink Model, refer to Using the Modeling Language.

Adding a predicate/relation

A predicate is a slot that links two instances of a class.

To add a predicate to Biolink Model you need to determine the following,

What is an appropriate name for this predicate?
- A human readable name for this predicate. It should capture the nature of the relationship
Where in the hierarchy does the new slot fit?
- Determine where in the related to hierarchy does this new predicate slot fit
What are the domain and range constraints (if any)?
- Determine which type of entity classes can this predicate link
What are the mapping(s) for this slot?
- Mappings are a way of rooting this new association in the context of other ontologies, thesauri, controlled vocabularies and taxonomies
- Determine the level of granularity for your mappings where they can be divided into 5 types: related_mappings, broad_mappings, narrow_mappings close_mappings, exact_mappings
  TODO: add the predicate discussion about inverse of cannon to this document.
Determine the inverse of the predicate, and add it (specifying the inverse property on each of the two predicates)
- In general, the canonical direction of the predicate should contain the descriptive information about the predicate while its inverse can be minimally defined.

As an example, let’s consider the definition of slot interacts with:

  interacts with:
    domain: named thing
    range: named thing
    description: >-
      holds between any two entities that directly or indirectly interact with each other
    is_a: related to
    in_subset:
      - translator_minimal
    symmetric: true
    exact_mappings:
      - RO:0002434
    narrow_mappings:
      - RO:0002103
      - RO:0002120
      - RO:0002130
      - SEMMEDDB:complicates

In the above YAML snippet, domain, range, description, is_a, in_subset, symmetric, exact_mappings and narrow_mappings are slots from linkML where each slot has a specific meaning and they add semantics to the slot definition.

For more information on what each slot means and how to use them in Biolink Model, refer to Using the Modeling Language.

Adding properties

You can add slots that represent node properties or edge properties.

To add a node/edge property to Biolink Model you need to determine the following,

What is an appropriate name for this slot?
- A human readable name for this property
Is it a node property or an edge property (association slot)?
- Determine whether the property is a node or an edge property
Where in the hierarchy does the new property fit?
- Determine where in the property hierarchy does this new property fit
- If you want to add a node property then it should be added as part of the node property hierarchy
- If you want to add an edge property then it should be added as part of the association slot hierarchy
Is this a required property?
- Determine whether all instances of a class must have a value for this property
What are the domain and range constraints (if any)?
- Determine which type of classes can have this property and what the value space for this property should be
What are the mapping(s) for this slot?
- Mappings are a way of rooting this new property in the context of other ontologies, thesauri, controlled vocabularies and taxonomies
- Determine the level of granularity for your mappings where they can be divided into 5 types: related_mappings, broad_mappings, narrow_mappings close_mappings, exact_mappings

As an example, let’s consider the slot name which is a node property:

  name:
    is_a: node property
    aliases: ['label', 'display name']
    domain: named thing
    range: label type
    description: >-
      A human-readable name for a thing
    in_subset:
      - translator_minimal
    required: true
    slot_uri: rdfs:label
    exact_mappings:
      - gff3:Name
      - gpi:DB_Object_Name

As another example, let’s consider the slot relation which is an edge property:

  relation:
    is_a: association slot
    description: >-
      The relation which describes an association between a subject and an object in a more granular manner.
      Usually this is a term from Relation Ontology, but it can be any edge CURIE.
    domain: association
    range: uriorcurie
    required: true

In the above YAML snippets, is_a, aliases, domain, range, description, in_subset, required, slot_uri, exact_mappings are slots from linkML where each slot has a specific meaning and they add semantics to the slot definition.

There are other linkML slots that can be used to define your class and represent the semantics of your class.

For more information on what each slot means and how to use them in Biolink Model, refer to Using the Modeling Language.

Managing mappings

In the previous sections there were references to mappings and differentiating these mappings based on their granularity, which can be a bit of a nuanced exercise.

What does it mean for a external concept (or predicate or property) to be one of related_mappings, broad_mappings, narrow_mappings close_mappings, exact_mappings?

Here is a rule of thumb on how to determine the granularity of mapping:

An external concept can be considered as an exact mapping to a Biolink Model class or slot if the former can be used interchangeably with the latter. That is, the semantics are identical and any transitive property that the external concept might bring into the model should not violate the internal consistency of the model
If it is difficult to determine if an external concept can be considered an exact mapping then it is much safer to treat it as a close mapping
If an external concept can be treated a sub-class of the Biolink Model class or slot then it can be treated as a narrow mapping
If an external concept can be treated as a super-class of the Biolink Model class or slot then it can be treated as a broad mapping
If an external concept is distantly related to a Biolink Model class or slot then it can be treated as a related mapping

Curating the Biolink Model

Adding an Entity class

Adding an Association class

Adding a predicate/relation

TODO: add the predicate discussion about inverse of cannon to this document.

Adding properties

Managing mappings